The definition of a COVER VERSION – A particular recording of a song is later re-recorded by someone else, in such a way that the new recording brings something new to the meaning of the song or the feelings it invokes. This is a series of posts about striking cover versions of songs.
Here is Part 1 about the nature of cover stories, with various examples – https://thekiddca.wordpress.com/2023/11/18/cover-stories-part-1-of-6/
Here is Part 2 featuring a dozen particularly good specific cover versions – https://thekiddca.wordpress.com/2023/11/24/cover-stories-part-2-of-6/
Here is Part 3 featuring a dozen more particularly good specific cover versions – https://thekiddca.wordpress.com/2023/12/02/cover-stories-part-3-of-6/
Here is Part 4 featuring a final dozen particularly good specific cover versions – https://thekiddca.wordpress.com/2023/12/09/cover-stories-part-4-of-6/
In this post a variety of songs which are closely related to the concept of cover versions will be discussed.
PARODIES
A parody is usually done to make fun of a song, perhaps to highlight negative about the song. This can be done with gentle humour by someone who actually likes the original song and is just having a bit of fun. It could, instead, be done by someone who is highly critical of the original song. Weird Al Yankovich, by all accounts, is a genuinely nice guy who just likes taking the mickey out of people, but he also obtains permission first from anyone whose song he intends to parody. Here is a highly popular song from early in Michael Jackson’s adult career – BEAT IT – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oRdxUFDoQe0&ab_channel=michaeljacksonVEVO . Here is EAT IT, a parody by Weird Al Yankovic of Beat It – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZcJjMnHoIBI&ab_channel=alyankovicVEVO
GENDER SWITCH
In some cases a song’s lyrics are written from the point of view of a particular gender but a new recording of the song is done by someone of a different gender who changes the lyric’s pronouns accordingly. Given the enormous gender-based power differential that still exists in today’s world, a particular lyric is likely to carry a very different meaning when delivered by one gender than it is being delivered by another. The traditional American folk song MAN OF CONSTANT SORROW has been recorded by Rod Stewart – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CdjaA752Cg0&ab_channel=RodStewart-Topic . Judy Collins also recorded the song but she changed it to MAID OF CONSTANT SORROW – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3zp8xUAO7Hs&ab_channel=swedishbaffe
In 1965 Otis Redding composed and recorded the song RESPECT from his male perspective – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KvC9V_lBnDQ&ab_channel=pieroangelo2 . Then in 1967 Aretha Franklin changed the lyrics slightly and recorded the song from a female perspective and it became a feminist anthem probably because, given the power imbalance, demanding (not begging for) respect is a hell of a lot harder for a woman to do than for a man to do (it was even harder in 1967) – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zF-gQP91iIE&ab_channel=MrsMattMurphy . Way back in 1952 African-American Big Mama Thornton recorded the song HOUND DOG (by Jerry Leiber and Mike Stoller) and not many people noticed – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BmpwvxW0gW0&ab_channel=RocknRoll then in 1956 Elvis Presley recorded the song and it was a big hit. This seems to be another case of a white singer covering a song released earlier by a black singer and making a fortune. Also, a woman calling a man a hound dog is more dangerous than a man calling a woman a hound dog – note the legendary guitarist Scotty Moore in Presley’s backup band here – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lzQ8GDBA8Is&ab_channel=jorgeollie .
Finally, the Donays was an American so-called Girl Group who had a hit with the Richard Drapkin song DEVIL IN HIS HEART – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PmLJ-p5adV8&ab_channel=TheDonays-Topic . Way back in 1963 (over sixty years ago!) The Beatles recorded this same song but reversed the gender of the villain of the piece. They changed the lyrics slightly and called it DEVIL IN HER HEART reinforcing that old misogynist trope of woman as evil seductress. This is also a rare case of lead guitarist George Harrison taking lead vocals even though it wasn’t one of his own songs (in almost all of the Beatles cover recordings John or Paul took lead vocals) – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IGe-jfFrxCk&ab_channel=TheBeatles-Topic .
In a variation of this idea, in the mid-1930’s in Germany male artists often sang the female lyrics to popular songs. These were called cross cover versions. This practice faded rapidly, however, as soon as the Nazis decided that such a practice was decadent.
FROM TIME TO TIME
Here are three unusual cases in which particular song or piece of music is originally written and recorded with a particular time signature and when it is covered a different time signature is used which can create a new unsettled or exotic feeling.
SWEET GEORGIA BROWN (by Ben Bernie and Maceo Pinkard) is heard here played by Benny Goodman in its original 4/4 time. Goodman is in his seventies here, and that’s the great Teddy Wilson on piano at the age of 68 – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0jE2g055zRA&ab_channel=SwingCla . Just for good measure, here is another cover version in 4/4 time by Brother Bones and his Shadows (released in 1949) which was used for years as the theme song of the Harlem Globetrotters, as seen in this ancient clip featuring the great Meadowlark Lemon – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xDLvbnoGA6M&ab_channel=tubengagements . Here is a much more sophisticated version by Dave Brubeck alternating between 7/4 time and 4/4 time. The excellent drummer is Dan Brubeck, Dave’s son, the cellist is his son Matthew, the bassist is his son Chris – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EA7ebL6Cuf8&ab_channel=LovelyDiscipline .
THE MAPLE LEAF RAG (by Scott Joplin) can be heard here played in its original form in 2/4 time by Paul Barton – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KYnR1zl7kFg&ab_channel=PaulBarton . Now here is an ingenious version by Johnny Guarnieri in 5/4 time (the music starts at the 1 min. 42 sec. mark) – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lHXxgC_ddbw&ab_channel=unigonfilms .
GREENSLEEVES is an English folk song dating from 1580 and it was originally written in 6/8 time, as heard here performed by The King’s Singers a cappella, i.e. unaccompanied (not an easy thing to do) – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=twix9KfES9Y&ab_channel=thekingssingers . Now here is still another version, this time in 4/4 time by Elyse Davis and the Mannheim Steamroller – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UllgHcFH58c&ab_channel=mannheimsteamroller . Neither of those time signatures is particularly unusual. However, here is a version in the highly unusual time signature of 7/4 recorded by the progressive rock band Jethro Tull – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RKNUrTdkDBw&ab_channel=CahitMeteOguz
OF MINOR CONCERN
THE MAPLE LEAF RAG (by Scott Joplin) can be heard here played in its original form in 2/4 time by Paul Barton – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KYnR1zl7kFg&ab_channel=PaulBarton . Now here is an ingenious version by Johnny Guarnieri in 5/4 time (the music starts at the 1 min. 42 sec. mark) – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lHXxgC_ddbw&ab_channel=unigonfilms .
GREENSLEEVES is an English folk song dating from 1580 and it was originally written in 6/8 time, as heard here performed by The King’s Singers a cappella, i.e. unaccompanied (not an easy thing to do) – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=twix9KfES9Y&ab_channel=thekingssingers . Now here is still another version, this time in 4/4 time by Elyse Davis and the Mannheim Steamroller – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UllgHcFH58c&ab_channel=mannheimsteamroller . Neither of those time signatures is particularly unusual. However, here is a version in the highly unusual time signature of 7/4 recorded by the progressive rock band Jethro Tull – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RKNUrTdkDBw&ab_channel=CahitMeteOguz
RENAISSANCE
Sometimes a song is resuscitated and covered later as part of another song, for example FOR WHAT IT’S WORTH (by Stephen Stills). The original version by Buffalo Springfield has Stephen Stills on guitar and a very young Neil Young (released 1967) – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JRV5LoOMyBk&ab_channel=sweetlikez . 32 years later we have a version by Public Enemy in 1999 weaving in and out of their song HE GOT GAME. Notice a much older Stephen Stills at 6 seconds in, at 47 seconds, and later at the 2 minute 18 second mark, and notice too the “man with a gun over there” at the 1 minute 42 second mark – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7FmPskTljo0&ab_channel=PublicEnemyVEVO
The Police recorded the song EVERY BREATH YOU TAKE in 1983 (sometimes referred to as I’ll Be Watching You). The song is about a stalker but some people took it as a love song, which is awfully creepy. Here is the striking video from the early days of music videos, full of subtle lighting effects, with Sting on stand-up bass – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OMOGaugKpzs&ab_channel=ThePoliceVEVO . In 1997 acclaimed rapper Notorious B.I.G. was murdered at the age of twenty-four. In response his friend P.Diddy released the song I’LL BE MISSING YOU singing with Faith Evans, the former wife of Notorious B.I.G., a song with words about the murder but with the same melody as the Police song, doing so with the good wishes of The Police. In fact here is a stirring live performance of the track with P.Diddy, Faith Evans and Sting – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V0nL7weZrp8&ab_channel=4dd7y5stars .
In 1975 Led Zeppelin released what I think is their best track, a song called ‘KASHMIR’. Then a full thirty-nine years later the 2014 terrible remake of Godzilla was released but the film’s soundtrack at least features P.Diddy performing a rap on top of that original Led Zeppelin track, with Jimmy Page of Led Zeppelin sneaking into the background of the accompanying dramatic music video.