From God to Satan, from the compassion of the Sisters of Mercy to the despair of Friedrich Nietzsche and praise for Tara, the Mother of all Buddhas . This is a series of posts about the politics and culture, the history and structure of music. Over the years I have watched and analysed hundreds of music videos, including some that are very good. The best one I’ve seen is about life and death, about hope and despair, about asking questions. It is intelligently crafted (note the captions), not particularly dramatic, it is realistic and different people will probably take it very different ways. The string arrangement is by former Led Zeppelin bass player John Paul Jones. The group is R.E.M. (two of its members are atheists, two aren’t) and the song is Everybody Hurts – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5rOiW_xY-kc&ab_channel=remhq .
This is a post about the music of Heaven, Hell and Utopia, with a reminder that the word ‘utopia’ means a perfect but non-existent place. It turns out that both the theists and the atheists out there have been creating some incredibly good music. There have been so many songs about religion, most pro but some con, that there is enough material for two posts (at least). This is the first one and it begins with a pair of opposites – an anguished plea to a very sinister Western God followed by an incredibly inspiring Tibetan ballad in praise of Tara, the deity of enlightenment and abundance. To begin with, Randy Newman has written highly controversial compositions about racism (Sail Away and Rednecks), sexual perversion (You Can Leave Your Hat On), and the end of the world (Political Science) but his most controversial piece, and I think his best one, is simply entitled God’s Song – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C0TvfqmWf4M&ab_channel=christianisgroovy . In contrast, here is Om Tare Tu Tara Ture Soha, a song from a group of accomplished blind musicians, a song of hope and healing, about seeing the spirit within when one’s vision outward has failed. Notice the intense focused reaction of the audience inside the auditorium as well as in the street outside, and the ovation at the end – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ayGQoJdRcdQ&ab_channel=KonSeaRing .Which of these two compositions do you find more comforting? More inspiring? More realistic? Is music created by non-religious composers just as good as music created by religious composers? It depends on how much musical skill the respective composers have, for one thing. Can a vision of life inspire great music even if that vision has no basis in reality? Of course it can, as long as the visionary isn’t aware of that disconnect with reality. Are we talking about more than one reality here? Devoutly religious people have done things both inspiring and compassionate, and cruel and horrific. The same is true of those who are not religious.
PLEASE NOTE: I have attempted to include a wide range of music in these posts, including music I don’t like but which is important or demonstrates a musical idea well. Almost any piece of music is interesting in some way. I recommend at least sampling all the music here – you might be pleasantly surprised. At least check out specific sections of compositions which I have identified. If you don’t like a clip just stop and jump to the next clip.
There have been many noteworthy grand works of religious music such as Handel’s Messiah and Mozart’s Requiem as well as shorter works such as Baba Yetu (this is the Lord’s Prayer in Swahili and here is an unusual and highly energetic performance of this work – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vsINANZ6Riw&ab_channel=AlexBoye ). Here are some other examples of well-executed religious musical compositions:
- I take this track to be U2’s devastating commentary on American religion – In God’s Country – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sERtcG-TUCU&ab_channel=U2VEVO
- A more nuanced take. Canadian singer, songwriter, poet Leonard Cohen, who is an observant Jew but who has also been ordained a Buddhist priest, has this to say about the Sisters of Mercy, members of an institute of Catholic women founded in Ireland in 1831 by Catherine McAuley – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uZkmPQQK92s&ab_channel=LOMEJORDELAMUSICA
- A fairly straightforward track – Madonna – Like a Prayer – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=79fzeNUqQbQ&ab_channel=Madonna
- The symphonic rock band Procol Harum has been releasing high quality material for decades, including a few unorthodox religious tracks, and this track is from what I think is their best record, about a dying man whose life has been a spiritual failure. The track is called Crucifiction Lane – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GCafiNz8hRs&ab_channel=InsanEssence
- Here is one of the better tracks by The Band, with help from the Staple Singers. The song is in 4 / 4 time but notice that the chorus consists of four bars of 4 / 4, then a bar of 3 / 4, then two more bars of 4 / 4. Also, 99.9% of all songs end on the tonic note of the scale of the key the song is written in. This song doesn’t – it ends on the sub-dominant rather than the tonic. The song is The Weight – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q-w9OclUnns&ab_channel=GreatOldiesDJ
- Here is a non-Christian religious song from the former lead guitarist with The Beatles, George Harrison. This exuberant up-tempo Hindu track is not very nice to Roman Catholicism, however, as one can see by the lines “The Pope owns 51% of General Motors. The stock exchange is the only thing he’s qualified to quote us”. Both EMI and Capitol Records who distributed the album containing the song in the UK and the US respectively deleted these lines from the lyric sheet accompanying the album. The song was produced by Phil Spector, has his trademark Wall of Sound feel to it, and is called Awaiting On You All – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QGI3RWBhuUo&ab_channel=J.Lauschner .
- A second religious song from George, Living in the Material World, which nicely swings back and forth between Western music and Indian music starting at the 1 minute 45 second mark, features Ringo Starr on drums and has a lovely rock and roll ending – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=31nvQDSzxrU&ab_channel=DwightWelch . Harrison’s best religious song by far is called Within You Without You but I won’t deal with it here. It is too complex musically to deal with it fairly here.
- There are many great religious musical compositions from the Baroque era including one which I (and most musical historians) consider to be the greatest (or certainly one of the greatest) piece of music ever created by anyone – I’m talking, of course, about The St. Matthew Passion, a highly religious work by J.S. Bach. However, Karajan’s recording of the work lasts 3 hours and 23 minutes so instead of linking to that I will give you another great religious work by Bach, Jesus bleibet meine Freude (Jesu, Joy of Man’s Desiring), less than four minutes long. It was composed in 1723, and sounds simple but isn’t, as is often the case with Bach. There are really two melodies, and the more dominant doesn’t begin until 27 seconds in and, gasp, is played by the left hand not the right. It flips over to the right hand later, and notice too how most of the notes are identical in length, a ridiculous but brilliant move on Bach’s part. Here is a 1947 recording of the thing by Lipatti – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k7PNFDrcqmY&ab_channel=ThePianoFiles .
Also, for a variety of atypical religious Christmas songs here are links to two of my previous posts – https://thekiddca.wordpress.com/2020/12/21/not-your-average-christmas-music/ and https://thekiddca.wordpress.com/2021/12/20/music-to-contemplate-christmas-by-christmas-2021/ .
In terms of a political God, in one of Bob Dylan’s early songs, recorded back in the days when his songs were worth a listen, before he became born again, we hear a careful, aggressive analysis of the political appropriation of God with some very evil intentions in the song With God On Our Side – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5y2FuDY6Q4M&ab_channel=BobDylanVEVO .
Then there are the songs focusing on the other side of the religious coin. The Rolling Stones’ most controversial song is Sympathy For the Devil and here’s a slightly different take on that classic song this time recorded by Guns ‘N’ Roses – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nyuBUkIKzWk&ab_channel=%E3%82%B8%E3%83%A7%E3%83%B3%E9%AB%98%E6%A9%8B The Rolling Stones also talked about Satan in another song in which Mr. D is, of course, the Devil, but at the end who is this person Mistress D? This is a track from the early 1970’s soon after Mick Taylor joined the band (he’s the one in the floral hat) re-placing co-founder guitarist Brian Jones dead at 27. Keith looks so young here – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9hw1SKn5eFM&ab_channel=TheRollingStones . There are most likely various heavy metal anthems to Satan out there as well but I suspect they’re all pretty generic and their primary goal is simply to provoke an outraged response from their elders.
George Harrison of The Beatles had strong religious feelings, but the other Beatle who he got along with best, and who was most like him, the leader John Lennon, was an atheist. This can be seen in perhaps Lennon’s most famous song after the break-up of The Beatles, a song that was highly praised and frequently covered and which outraged many on the religious right in the United States – Imagine – The lines that got him into trouble were: “Imagine there’s no heaven / It’s easy if you try / No hell below us / Above us only sky.” Previously The Beatles also released a song that was banned in some parts of the United States, a track called The Ballad of John and Yoko. In that case the lines that got the song banned were: “The way things are going / They’re going to crucify me”. Just to keep the record straight, at one point the religious right in the southern United States made the false claim that John Lennon had said that The Beatles were better than God, a claim that led to death threats on their subsequent U.S. tour. Lennon had said, out of sorrow more than anything else, that at the height of Beatlemania The Beatles had more of an influence on the lives of teenagers than the church, a statement that no one objected to in Britain at the time or since.
Here is a track by the phenomenal vocalist Harry Nilsson but though it purports to be in praise of God I think he’s really mocking God here. Would a Supreme Deity be offended by something like this? Of course not. She (or He) would probably put it down to immature rebelliousness. Background vocals are by Ringo Starr on this track – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C_-gKhc3qFw&ab_channel=KenG
Finally, a series of songs that seem to be sceptical about religion:
- How the Kinks (and composer Ray Davies) perceive organized revolution is stated clearly in their song Uncle Son but their opinion of God herself / himself can be gleaned from their track Big Sky – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wiyrFSSG5_g&ab_channel=CoolPomegranate .
- The Doors’ track The Soft Parade begins on a dramatic religious note. The charismatic lead singer Jim Morrison can be heard saying – “When I was back there in Seminary school there was a person there who put forth the proposition that you can petition the Lord with prayer. Petition the Lord with prayer. Petition the Lord with prayer.” There is a long pause, then he screams one more line: “You cannot petition the Lord with prayer !!! “ then he goes into the song. It’s almost nine minutes long and there’s not much to it so I won’t provide a link, but it’s got an arresting opening.
- The anarcho-punk band Chumbawamba from Leeds, England recorded a rather strange but catchy song about some people who seem to have started out religious but became disillusioned – We Don’t Go To God’s House No More – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P1JawSJJggE&ab_channel=p00k .
We started with Randy Newman. Here is another song of his in which someone is talking to a lonely old man abandoned by all his friends except one, and about to die. The singer, without malice, reminds the old man, however, how in earlier times the old man had taught the speaker that God did not exist. This is not a happy song. It’s called Old Man – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pVpUr5luo6k&ab_channel=RandyNewman-Topic .
Before I provide a link with another, more light-hearted religious track by Randy Newman, a brief foray into the life of the enigmatic highly influential iconoclastic German philosopher Friedrich Nietzsche is in order. Nietzsche was a progressive thinker and a harsh opponent of antisemitism and nationalism but his name later became connected with Nazism in part because his antisemitic sister edited and distorted his writings after he died. Nietzsche could read Latin, Hebrew, French and Greek as well as German so he could read primary sources, and he studied theology and philology intending to become a minister. His brilliance was rewarded when he became a professor at the University of Basel at the ridiculously young age of 24. He also served as a medical orderly in the Franco-Prussian War, and he even composed music and was a friend of musical giants Franz Liszt and Richard Wagner. He suffered serious physical and later mental problems throughout his life, however, and died at the age of fifty-five. In 1882 he wrote about a man who runs excitedly into the village square and proclaims:
God is dead. God remains dead. And we have killed him. How shall we comfort ourselves, the murderers of all murderers? What was holiest and mightiest of all that the world has yet owned has bled to death under our knives: who will wipe this blood off us? What water is there for us to clean ourselves? What festivals of atonement, what sacred games shall we have to invent? Is not the greatness of this deed too great for us? Must we ourselves not become gods simply to appear worthy of it?”
Nietzsche was talking here about the triumph of scientific rationality over sacred revelation as a result of The Enlightenment which unfolded during the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries.
Randy Newman decided to run with this idea and he released a song explaining that God isn’t dead, he’s hiding – I Think He’s Hiding – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nuL70a9xpD8&ab_channel=RandyNewman-Topic .
Before I end with a final set of three tracks, a few things which need to be said about atheism:
- Some ask why atheists choose to reject God as if they have a choice. If an objective rational assessment of reality based on evidence and logic is made and the concept of God is found to have no merit then the atheist has no choice but to reject theism even though of course it would be much nicer if there were things like an afterlife and a loving God.
- That you have to be religious to be moral is nonsense, and insulting. A fundamentalist behaves in order to avoid eternal fiery torture. An atheist behaves because it is the ethical thing to do. Atheists, without the prospect of Hell, could behave horribly but their behaviour is far better than that of religious fanatics. Shall we talk about the Inquisition and the Crusades, not to mention the lives destroyed by religious fundamentalists?
- Theists praise God and give him credit for rainbows and kittens (as if refraction and evolution had never been discovered), and for more subtle things as well like human compassion. As the old Anglican hymn puts it, “All things bright and beautiful / all things great and small / all things wise and wonderful / the Lord God made them all.” Monty Python had an answer to that of course – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yEKDYIYMgBc&ab_channel=BlessedHerman . Apparently God also made terminal cancer in children along with the 2011 Tohoku earthquake and tsunami that killed 19747 people in Japan alone, not to mention the Holocaust and the Slave Trade. If you argue, as most theologians do, that the Holocaust and the Slave Trade were necessary to give humankind free will, then you have to assume a non-interventionist God which makes the idea of prayer laughable. A non-interventionist God means we’re talking about Deism, that is a God that might as well not exist now that he / she has started things going. What many Americans don’t realize is that several of the founding fathers of their country were deists. The free will argument also doesn’t excuse childhood terminal diseases and lethal natural disasters.
- The Ontological Argument, The Cosmological Argument, The Teleological Argument and other arguments for theism have also all been soundly discredited.
I will end this post with three amazing videos with profound religious implications from three very religious people. The first is from the Man in Black, Johnny Cash, whose religious feelings were extremely strong and raw and honest. The track is called God’s Gonna Cut You Down. Kris Kristofferson, Sheryl Crow, The Dixie Chicks, Bono, Brian Wilson, Keith Richards and his skull ring, and others, make appearances here – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eJlN9jdQFSc&ab_channel=JohnnyCashVEVO . The second video was made by the great David Bowie just days before he died of cancer and I can’t get this one out of my head. This is how this masterful individual chose to leave this world. The song is called Lazarus – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y-JqH1M4Ya8&ab_channel=DavidBowieVEVO . The most powerful song of the three, the most important song I have heard in years, is a darker take on religion recorded by the devoutly religious Leonard Cohen shortly before he died. This is actually a video of an event which took place in Montreal, Leonard Cohen’s home town, a few days after his death. The voice, of course, is Cohen’s and everything else is live. This is intensely moving and dark, and I am not sure how to interpret the lyrics. I will leave that up to you. The song is called You Want It Darker? – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XF6JcrSfUwE&ab_channel=CarlBrabant .
There is a lot to think about here.
NEXT POST: HEAVEN, HELL AND UTOPIA Part 2 of 2 From the Prince of Peace to The Prodigal Son, Blind Faith to The Inner Light.
MUSIC TO YOUR EARS
Posts already posted or still being planned as we speak:
- STAND TO ATTENTION, OR ELSE – Anthems, National and Unofficial. From Black Power to one small flower of eternity, from Oceania ‘Tis of Thee to Lift Every Voice and Sing – https://thekiddca.wordpress.com/2021/09/22/music-to-your-ears-1-stand-to-attention-or-else/
- WHY? – Twenty-five purposes and functions of music. From Pressed Rat and Warthogto Rainy Day Women Number Twelve and Thirty-five, from propaganda to religion, labour relations to storytelling – https://thekiddca.wordpress.com/2021/09/29/music-to-your-ears-2-why/
- LISTEN UP – Things to listen for when you listen to a piece of music. From Kashmir to Vine Street, St. James Infirmary to Scarborough Fair – https://thekiddca.wordpress.com/2021/10/06/music-to-your-wars-3-listen-up/
- THE BRIGHT SIDE OF LIFE – Silly and Satirical Songs. From vegetables to metaphysical dogma, inebriated philosophers to short people – https://thekiddca.wordpress.com/2021/10/14/music-to-your-ears-4-the-bright-side-of-life/
- THE COMPLEXITIES OF WAR – https://thekiddca.wordpress.com/2021/10/21/music-to-your-ears-5-the-complexities-of-war/
- HOMELAND AND LIFE: A Case Study – An examination of the recent explosive viral video Patria y Vida – https://thekiddca.wordpress.com/2021/10/27/music-to-your-ears-6-homeland-and-life/
- REALITY CHECK – From Kristallnacht to the Long March, massive floods and burning rivers, Wounded Knee to the École Polytechnique – Music memorializing real events – https://thekiddca.wordpress.com/2021/11/03/music-to-your-ears-7-reality-check/
- CINEMATIC MUSIC – From the Squid Game to the Witcher in the heat of the night in the darkest depths of Mordor – how music offers an added dimension to the cinematic experience – https://thekiddca.wordpress.com/2021/11/10/music-to-your-ears-8-cinematic-music/
- DRAMATIS PERSONAE – From Nelson Mandela to Albert Einstein, Harriet Tubman to Sally Ride – Music celebrating real people – https://thekiddca.wordpress.com/2021/11/17/music-to-your-ears-9-dramatis-personae/
- THE BEATLES – GOOD, BAD AND WRONG – From The Rolling Stones to Pete Best, from Lucy in the Sky with Diamonds to the Walrus – things about The Beatles rarely said but which need to be said – https://thekiddca.wordpress.com/2021/11/22/music-to-your-ears-10-the-bad-the-good-and-the-wrong/
- MUSIC LEFT AND RIGHT – From the King to the Kid, Uncle Son to Joe Hill – music from the extremes of the political spectrum – https://thekiddca.wordpress.com/2021/12/02/music-to-your-ears-11-music-right-and-left/
- MUSIC LEFT AND RIGHT REDUX – Further thoughts about MUSIC LEFT AND RIGHT – https://thekiddca.wordpress.com/2021/12/08/music-left-and-right-redux/
- DANCE TO THE MUSIC – From Slim and Slam to ring shouts and the macabre. – dances political, religious and silly – https://thekiddca.wordpress.com/?p=5344
- STREAMING AUDIO – Third Stream Music from Bach as Rock to Yiddish Reggae – deftly combining broad categories of music – https://thekiddca.wordpress.com/2022/01/05/music-to-your-ears-14-streaming-audio/
- INVISIBLE GENIUSES – Session Musicians and Guest Musicians – an appreciation of great musicians you have probably never heard of – https://thekiddca.wordpress.com/2022/01/12/music-to-your-ears-14-invisible-virtuosi/
- THE EVOLUTION OF MUSIC 2700 BCE to 1900 CE – From a Satanic violinist to a blues master who sold his soul to the Devil at the Crossroads – https://thekiddca.wordpress.com/2022/01/19/music-to-your-ears-16-the-dramatic-evolution-of-music-part-1-of-3/
- THE EVOLUTION OF MUSIC 1900 to 1980 CE – From Big Mama and Smokey to Bill Haley’s Comets and the Flamingos – https://thekiddca.wordpress.com/2022/01/26/music-to-your-ears-17-the-dramatic-evolution-of-music-part-2-of-3/
- THE EVOLUTION OF MUSIC 1966 to 2022 – From troubadours who die before they reach Bombay to wisdom from the Tibetan Book of the Dead – https://thekiddca.wordpress.com/2022/02/02/music-to-your-ears-18-the-dramatic-evolution-of-music-part-3-of-3/
- HEAVEN, HELL AND UTOPIA – Part 1 of 2. From God to Satan, from the compassion of the Sisters of Mercy to the despair of Friedrich Nietzsche.
- HEAVEN, HELL AND UTOPIA – Part 2 of 2. From the Prince of Peace to the Prodigal Son, Blind Faith to The Inner Light.
- Musical Families – musical dynasties
GHOST STORIES. In preparation as a break from the endless music posts, these are stories about people no longer alive who did important and amazing things, sometimes risking their lives, but were largely unknown or are now forgotten. From the ENIAC Girls and the Zamani Soweto Sisters to The Wrecking Crew and master magician and charlatan nemesis Harry Houdini and his secret operatives.