PARADES OF GREY-SUITED GRAFTERS, A CHOICE OF CANCER AND POLIO (M.Jagger, K.Richard)
I read last week that Marjorie Taylor-Greene is the most probable choice to be the running mate of Ron DeSantis in the 2024 Presidential election in the United States. I live in Canada and what happens in the United States indirectly affects what happens here. Given how there is also talk about Republicans abandoning Trump, will they embrace DeSantis (who is as nasty as Trump but smarter), will DeSantis / Greene win in 2024? The democrats don’t seem to have a strong candidate in the wings, Biden is not particularly good at his job and his popularity waxes and wanes. Unfortunately the people who should be President of the United States, like Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez or perhaps Elizabeth Warren (but not Hilary Clinton) are probably not electable. So, if DeSantis / Greene are victorious, will they act in accordance with what the majority of the people in America want? I doubt it. This is not democracy in action.
“It’s here the family’s broken, and it’s here the lonely say, that the heart has got to open in a fundamental way”
DEMOCRACY – Leonard Cohen – with an excellent backing band including Dino Soldo on mouth harp and the great Webb Sisters (Charley and Hattie) on vocals.
We hear quite a bit these days about the dangerous rapid decline of democracy in the United States. Are these alarmist exaggerations or is there some substance to the claims? After all democracy is declining pretty quickly in places like Poland and Hungary. Democracy is gone in North Korea, and I don’t think it was ever there in China. But what about the United States? When in doubt, look at the data:
In recent years some countries have become more democratic but others have become less, a process known as autocratization. According to the Economist Intelligence Unit (EIU), the research division of the UK-based company that publishes the highly esteemed newspaper The Economist, in 2016 the United States slipped down from being a ‘Full Democracy’ to being a ‘Flawed Democracy’. Will this trend continue? When did the factors causing this to happen first begin to emerge?
Donald Trump expressed his wish to have five African-American teenagers executed, after those same teenagers had been proven innocent of a crime they had been accused of. He bragged of sexually attacking women. He was known to refuse to pay workers for work done. And so many other things. All this before the 2016 election. I like to think that the number of Americans who disapprove of this behaviour outnumber those who are okay with it. Yet he won in 2016. Yes, I know that Hilary Clinton received three million more votes than Trump but the Trump victory stood. As it was it was disgusting that he got as many votes as he did given that he was not only nasty, but incompetent. The will of the people was not reflected in the 2016 election. We can thank the Electoral College, and the Primaries, for that.
This week eleven people died in a mass shooting in California, then a few days later seven more people died in a second mass shooting. Then there was Uvalde, and Sandy Hook, and so many others, including many incidents of individual handgun-related murders, accidental deaths and suicides. I know that the pro-gun lobby say that they are as appalled as the anti-gun lobby at these killings but there is hard and fast evidence that the pro-gun lobby’s assertions regarding how to stop these killings are simply wrong. On the other hand polls tell us that the majority of Americans want tougher gun control legislation. No such legislation exists. The will of the people has been stymied again and lots of people are dying unnecessarily because of it. One could also talk about reproductive rights, capital punishment and other issues. The United States is clearly not democratic. What’s going on?
I have heard it argued that when the United States was born it was anything but a democracy. For a start, all women, and all African-Americans had no legal right to the vote. African-Americans were in fact designated as being three-fifths of a human being. Some would say that the American nation was founded by a group of rich white males whose aim was to maintain their own power and control over the economy and the populace in general. Eight of the early presidents were slave owners, for example. That’s a complicated matter for a separate post. It is true, however, that lies have been circulated regarding the founding fathers, a group of flawed human beings worshipped as minor gods by many Americans. Many of the founding fathers were deists, for example, and they also may not have had the best interests of the average person in mind when they designed their new nation. Even if one grants that the United States at least attempted to become more democratic over the centuries since its inception, there are signs that it is no longer doing so. People have suggested various points at which the United States ceased to aspire toward democracy and started to become an autocracy:
- The pardoning of Richard Nixon after Watergate
- Letting Ronald Reagan off the hook after Contragate
- The Supreme Court stealing the presidency from Al Gore
- President Obama letting the banks off the hook in 2008 followed by the creation of the Tea Party Movement in 2009
- The election of Donald Trump
Why didn’t people riot in the streets when Nixon was pardoned? He was pardoned by the Republican Party. Why, after the pardon, didn’t every eligible voter (except the few who were on Nixon’s side) who voted in an election for Senate, House of Representative, Governor, Dog Catcher and so on simply refuse to vote for a Republican? The same with Trump and all the rest. Some of the phenomena which work to undermine democracy:
- Neoliberalism
- Neoconservatism
- Government support for the interests of corporations coupled with anti-union activity
- The loosening of campaign finance laws (e.g. the Citizens United decision)
- Rising inequality in wealth and political influence
- The rise of Christian nationalism / white supremacy
- The erosion of reproductive rights
- The rise of the conservative judiciary (assisted by the Federalist Society)
- The refusal to accept legitimate electoral outcomes
- Voter suppression
- Lack of meaningful gun control legislation
- Increasing intolerance toward the LGBTQI community
- The influence of Fox News, Newsmax and One America News
Are any or all of these things happening in the United States? Are they happening with greater frequency and intensity than previously? Will they continue to happen?
On the other hand, what does democracy look like? What forms can democracy take, and are those forms commonplace in the United States? Are they diminishing? How present are they compared with other countries? Democratic institutions and practices include freedom of expression, freedom of the press, freedom of speech and internet democracy for a start, all of which will help to ensure that the electorate are well informed so that they can vote in their own interest. Other aspects of democracy include freedom of assembly and association, freedom of religion, inclusiveness, consent of the governed, voting rights and minority rights.
Dilemmas also arise. What if the voice of some of the people want to take away the voice of some other people? According to a Jardina and Mickey poll in 2022 approximately a third of Americans want “a strong leader who doesn’t have to bother with Congress or elections”, and approximately one quarter were actually in favour of military rule. If those minorities become majorities than the United States will have become de facto anti-democratic. Are the people expressing these views working against their own self-interest? Is it tribal warfare we’re talking about?
Furthermore, in recent years many voters in the United States have complained quite justifiably that there’s not a lot of point in voting if both choices are terrible (or if their vote isn’t even counted). Of course it is still essential to vote despite lack of choice since a nasty powerful politician can be far worse for the citizenry than a mediocre politician. Though third parties have come and gone, with little effect and staying power, there remain only two choices, Democrats or Republicans. In Canada there are three viable parties federally and even more regionally. So in the United States many eligible voters stay at home.
“Spare a thought for the stay-at-home voter, His empty eyes gaze at strange beauty shows”
SALT OF THE EARTH – The Rolling Stones back in the day when they were much more political, and worth listening to. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eOiLH-2hTPQ&ab_channel=ABKCOVEVO
But all is not lost. Many Americans are pushing back against those attempting to dismantle their democracy. I have just finished reading ‘One Person, No Vote; by Carol Anderson. It does a comprehensive job of detailing and analysing the process of voter oppression primarily against African-Americans, but also against the poor generally, in the United States. Despite the long and bloody history of preventing African-Americans from voting, an oppressive process carried out with more subtlety now than in previous decades but still going on, I was impressed by the response to those anti-democratic initiatives. The African-American response has been well-organized, determined, strong and courageous, with many lives lost along the way, but it has also had considerable success. There is presently a long list of organizations working skilfully to dismantle voter suppression. This is impressive.
Throughout history there have been attempts to establish democracies but remember that many states that called themselves democracies, and had legislation promoting democracy, were democratic in name only, and their pro-democracy laws were either never enforced, or enforced selectively only against the poor and minorities. It was not uncommon for political leaders to pretend to lead democratically as a way of keeping people from rebelling when in fact they knew, and were all right with the moneyed classes, and, as capitalism developed, the corporate elites, pulling the strings behind the scenes.
Things are not always what they seem. Back when it was a country, the extremely undemocratic East Germany’s official name was ‘Deutsche Demokratische Republik (German Democratic Republic)’. In Russia Vladimir Lenin basically invented what has been called democratic centralism in 1902 (in his work ‘What Is To Be Done?’) but Russia has been not just undemocratic but anti-democratic for about a century. By the way Russia also calls itself Communist but according to classical Marxist theory Russia has been very uncommunistic for over a century as well. It is categorized as Authoritarian by the EIU.
“I support the left, though I’m leaning to the right”
POLITICIAN – Cream – 2005
Democratic centralism is also specifically enshrined in the Constitution of present day China (Article 3) but there isn’t very much democracy in China. It became somewhat less autocratic with the clandestine ground-breaking appearance of anti-collectivist music by Cui Jian, the emergence of yaogun into the mainstream, and the rise of bands such as Tang Dynasty and Cobra. However, China is still anything but democratic. It is categorized as Authoritarian by the EIU.
“Boss man, Boss man, what do you say, gonna get you alone in the mine some day”:
BOSS MAN – Gordon Lightfoot
Some have also declared that capitalism is by its nature undemocratic, and those in power in the United States have taken capitalism to whole new levels. It’s certainly true that advanced capitalism is anti-union and would never abide by phenomena such as worker-owned businesses. Capitalism is based on private ownership of the means of production designed to generate profit. It requires competitive markets and if they can’t be found domestically then you end up with imperialism and colonialism (and the mass murder and atrocities that often go with them), and the exploitation of foreign labour to the detriment of domestic workers. Capitalism also gives us periodic depressions and recessions – it’s built into the system. The rampant materialism of profit-driven corporatism has invaded the political sphere and things like human rights, economic equality and an equitable distribution of power and influence have all been ignored. And how exactly do advanced monopoly capitalist regimes maintain control, and keep the dissenters in the Labour Movement, and the spiritual leaders in the Liberation Theology Movement, from making progress in their attempts to dismantle corporate networks? The methods of the powers that be often include misdirection and racism, cynicism, even patriotic armed conflict:
MISDIRECTION
“To keep up his hate, so he never thinks straight, ‘bout the shape that he’s in”
ONLY A PAWN IN THEIR GAME – Bob Dylan (Note: Medgar Evers was a prominent Civil Rights activist who was the victim of assassination)
CYNICISM
“ ‘Til the pain is so big you feel nothing at all”
WORKING CLASS HERO – John Lennon
PATRIOTIC ARMED CONFLICT
“The patriot’s dream is as old as the sky, it lives in the lust of a cold callous lie”
THE PATRIOT’S DREAM – Gordon Lightfoot
That’s unregulated capitalism, and deregulation gathered steam under President Reagan and has continued to thrive under more recent Republican regimes. But what about regulated capitalism? Or mixed economies and socialist financial structures? The word ‘socialism’ is one of those words, like ‘democracy’ itself, which is an umbrella term for a wide range of possibilities. Socialism, if nothing else, is clearly more democratic than straight capitalism given that the nations that hover around the top of the list of the world’s most democratic states are at least partially socialist. By the way, many right wing politicians also equate socialism with communism, of course, intentionally, as a scare tactic, when they are in fact quite different. American conservatives also talk about dangerous leftists in the Democratic Party when in fact the Democratic Party in America is to the right of centre on the Canadian political spectrum. It is laughable.
There are some who are not in favour of democracy. Plato didn’t believe in democratic ideals at all. He was a great philosopher, but guess who he thought should be in charge of society? Philosophers. What a surprise. Read all about Philosopher Kings (not the Canadian rock band) in Plato’s ‘Republic’ (Part III, Book V, Chapter XVIII). However democracy to my mind is the best way to go but to do that you need to have an electorate who have been trained in critical thinking at school, who have access to complete and accurate information about the political environment, and who are incentivised to use that information. People need to know how to vote in their own best interest. They need to vote using logic not emotion, policies not personalities.
But not to despair. Democracy is still alive and kicking in the world. According to the Varieties of Democracy Institute (an independent research institute) which has ranked nations on scales of electoral democracy, participatory democracy, liberal democracy, deliberative democracy and egalitarian democracy, the five most democratic nations in the world are, in descending order, Denmark, Sweden, Costa Rica, Norway and New Zealand. Other countries in the top twenty include Canada, Finland, the United Kingdom, Ireland and The Netherlands. These are all categorized as full democracies. Number thirty-three on the list is the United States, lower than countries such as Argentina and Slovakia. The EIU ranks Canada at 12, with the United States at twenty-six on the list of the most democratic nations.
So, time will tell whether the United States can move from being a Flawed Democracy back up into the Full Democracy category, or whether it will continue down the road to autocracy. For now:
“You mothafuckas owe me, Grandma told me, Get your money black man”)
THIS IS AMERICA – Childish Gambino (2018)
“When I think of the road we’re travelling on, I wonder what’s gone wrong”
AMERICAN TUNE – Paul Simon (1975)
I don’t know what to think when all is said and done. I see millions of American voters elect an openly boastful sexual predator, a grifter and racist, to be president in 2016. I see far too much racism, misogyny and xenophobia on the rise. The electorate are grasping at straws. But I also see plenty of anonymous Americans working hard to push back against the decline of democracy. The undemocratic legal framework in place, the cultural impetus to be cynical and resigned, the widespread misinformation being disseminated, and the growing economic inequality designed to distract people from an accurate assessment of the power structure, all make it difficult to make progress.
“Indeed it has been said that democracy is the worst form of government except for all those other forms that have been tried” – Winston Churchill, Nov. 11, 1947, in the House of Commons
I am no fan of Churchill. He was a racist, an imperialist and a staunch monarchist, but I give him full credit for this quote. After capably leading Britain to victory in World War Two as Prime Minister he was voted out of office democratically in 1945 when the British citizenry in their wisdom voted Clement Attlee in as Prime Minister for Labour. This quote comes after Churchill’s defeat. No complaints from him about election fraud.
I’d recommend something revolutionary except that all the revolutions I’m aware of ultimately failed. The Russian Revolution in 1917, and the revolution in China in 1949, led to disaster and tragedy on a massive scale despite good intentions. Better not to heed Elton John’s advice (burn down the mission). If you decide to stage a second American Revolution, good luck to you.
“There’ll be fighting in the streets, with our children at our feet”
WON’T GET FOOLED AGAIN – The Who in 2000 – with Noel Gallagher of Oasis – at the Royal Albert Hall: